AFCEN-PTAN-06002-2024

The aim of this document is to compare and analyse the compatibility of the RCC-F with some fire reference documents. For each reference document, the compatibility is provided in a dedicated appendix.
The first version of this document compared RCC-F 2020 with WENRA Safety Reference Levels (SRL) 2014 [1]. The compatibility analysis is presented in appendix 1.
The present version complements the document with the appendix 2 which provides the analysis of the compatibility of the RCC-F 2024 with the WENRA SRL 2020 [2]. At first, a comparison between WENRA SRL 2014 and 2020 is given as well as the impact of the evolution of the SRL on the compatibility evaluated in appendix 1. And after, this appendix analyses the Safety Reference Levels 2020 with no equivalence in the 2014 version.

To appreciate the compatibility of the RCC-F with the reference documents, four criterions are used:
• A: the principles of the article are fully applied in the RCC-F
• B: the principles of the requirement expressed by the article are applied in the RCC-F but not explicitly expressed
• C: the article is applied in the RCC-F as a recommendation but not as a requirement
• D: the article is not applied in the RCC-F

[1] Report - WENRA Safety Reference Levels for Existing Reactors – Update in Relation to Lessons Learned from TEPCO Fukushima Dai-ichi Accident 24th September 2014